The serve that rewrote New York, and why it matters now
Carlos Alcaraz just completed one of the most airtight serving fortnights in recent Grand Slam history. He won 98 of 101 service games during his title run at the 2025 US Open, a mark the ATP notes has been matched by only a handful of men since 1991. That number is not hype, it is documented in ATP confirms 98 of 101, and it frames how opponents must adjust in the Asian swing that follows September in New York. For more context on the New York numbers, see our 98 of 101 holds breakdown.
Fast forward a few weeks and the patterns from Flushing Meadows are already traveling. On September 28, 2025, Alcaraz punched his ticket to the Tokyo semifinals, again looking untroubled on serve in the late rounds according to Reuters Tokyo semifinals report. Tokyo is outdoor hard court with a roof option, the air is heavy at night, and the ball can sit up just enough to reward big first‑strike tennis. That environment can amplify a server who backs the delivery with an aggressive plus one. Which is why the next two sections matter to coaches, juniors, and parents trying to build a practical plan. For broader context on technology and coaching windows in Asia, scan our Asian swing coaching tech.
What actually makes Alcaraz’s serve plus one so hard to crack
You cannot reduce Alcaraz’s serve to raw pace. His average first‑serve speed is elite, but the dominance comes from location diversity, disguise, and how quickly he repossesses center court for the plus one. Think of three levers that work together.
-
Location variety that still targets patterns: Alcaraz covers all three basic lanes on both sides, yet he toggles between high‑percentage body jam serves and alley‑threatening wides that make you defend outside your hips. He rarely gets stuck repeating the same exact seam twice without a purpose. When he does repeat, it is usually to prime the plus one, not because he ran out of ideas.
-
Toss and rhythm disguise: His toss needle barely moves on flat, slice, or kick variations. The result is delayed recognition for the returner, which steals the first step. The rhythm also hides intention. He has no obvious pause that telegraphs wide slice or body.
-
Plus one speed and spacing: The first forehand after the serve arrives sooner than you expect because he crowds the baseline on contact, lands balanced, and immediately takes ground with his left leg. The plus one is not just fast, it arrives to the opponent’s weaker contact height. Deep and chest‑high to backhand is a theme.
Put these together and you get a serve phase that rarely offers the returner the same ball twice in the same space, followed by a ball that arrives before the defender finishes the recover step. That is why the hold streak in New York was not a mirage and why the same patterns are biting in Tokyo.
Where the patterns show up by court side
-
Deuce court, wide slice set play: He threatens the wide slider that drags a right‑hander off court, and his plus one prefers inside‑in if you float the return. When the returner overplays the angle to cut off the slice, he goes body or T and jams the backhand ribcage.
-
Ad court, body‑to‑backhand bias: Against right‑handers, the ad body serve pins the backhand shoulder and funnels a central, neutral reply. From there he can choose inside‑out forehand or a quick backhand up the line to take time. The ad T serve appears more at score protection points, especially when he wants a clean first strike without giving the returner angle.
-
Second serve, elevated kick to backhand: He uses the kick as a platform to take the baseline on the next ball. He is happy to start a plus one rally with margin if it means he wins court position.
These are not absolutes, they are recurring themes. Film study across New York and his first Tokyo matches shows the same footprint, adjusted for conditions. The roof in Tokyo reduces wind, the night air slows the through‑court bounce a touch, and that makes the wide slice hold its line while giving his follow‑up forehand a predictable height. If you prepare with that in mind, your return plan improves immediately.
The return plan that has a real chance in Asia
Here is a four‑pillar framework coaches can build this week. It blends tactical choices with footwork and reception skills. Each pillar includes a specific on‑court drill you can run tomorrow. For a complementary look at counter‑patterns, review our Fritz Laver Cup blueprint.
1) Return depth shifts that move his strike zone
Goal: Change where Alcaraz meets his plus one so he cannot preload inside‑in forehand rhythm.
-
First‑serve plan: Begin one shoe length deeper than your norm, square stance, split step timed to his trophy drop. Commit to blocking the ball back through the center stripe at a height that lands near baseline N to U on the singles lines. Depth to the middle denies angles and buys a step for the next ball. If he serves wide deuce, your block goes high deep middle, not to the alley.
-
Second‑serve plan: Take a half step in and use a punchy, compact swing, hips stable, to lift the return heavy into his backhand half. The goal is a deep, high ball that arrives at his shoulder, which reduces his ability to accelerate the plus one.
Drill: Ladder depth returns. Coach feeds first serves from the service line with pace. The returner alternates A) block deep middle, B) step inside and punch deep heavy to backhand half. Score 15‑0 for a deep middle contact that lands within two feet of the baseline. Miss long is zero, miss in the net is minus one.
2) Body‑serve anticipation without guessing
Goal: Preempt the ribcage jam without opening the alley.
-
Read cues: When Alcaraz shortens the toss height or quickens the rhythm on big points in the ad court, expect body. Keep your outside foot half a shoe inside your default mark. Hands start higher so you can short‑hop the ball.
-
Contact plan: Use a compact, shoulder‑led block that keeps the ball straight through the court, not side‑spin to the sideline. Think firm strings to the belly button, straight out, finish short.
Drill: Body buffer. Server aims body ten balls in a row. Returner’s rule is simple, every ball must clear the service line by at least four feet and travel within a two‑rack‑width channel down the center. Add a penalty sprint for any return that bleeds to the sideline, since that invites the plus one into open court.
3) Chip and float to neutralize the plus one
Goal: Remove pace and break his timing window on the first groundstroke after the serve.
-
Backhand chip: On wide serves, especially deuce side, chip low and skid the ball back toward the big triangle between service line T and baseline center. The low ball forces him to hit up, which steals some of his forehand acceleration.
-
Occasional float: If he is over‑committing to the inside‑in forehand, throw a deep floater that lands safely within two feet of the baseline middle. The deep float is not a bail out, it is a design choice to make him generate all the pace.
Drill: Skid and float ladder. Alternate five skids, five floats. Skids must pass the net under the top third of the tape height, floats must pass over the top third. Track his contact height in practice. If he is hitting chest‑high on ball two, you are succeeding.
4) Deuce‑court pattern traps that spring the counter
Goal: Use your starting position and first strike to funnel his plus one into your ambush.
-
Bait wide, steal middle: Start half a step toward the alley on deuce, hips slightly open. If the serve goes wide, chip cross and sprint back to cover the line. If it goes T or body, your starting shape gives you a cleaner contact to send the ball deep middle, which blunts the forehand inside‑in.
-
Early backhand line: When he serves body deuce and the ball sits around hip height, take the backhand early down the line. This makes him hit a running forehand into a narrow lane. You are choosing a tough shot early to avoid an impossible one later.
Drill: Deuce trap live points. Server can hit any deuce‑side serve. Returner must either A) chip cross and recover or B) take backhand line. Play short games first to three with returner scoring two points for any rally where the second ball Alcaraz would hit lands outside the singles sideline or nets. The emphasis is on trapping the plus one, not just putting the return in play.
What this looks like on the Tokyo court
Tokyo is outdoor hard at Ariake, and night sessions often feel heavier. The ball stays on the strings a fraction longer and the roof, when closed, removes wind. Those conditions favor the wide deuce slice, since it holds its line, and they also reward body‑serve jammers that sit up enough to be attacked by the server if the return is short. That is why the depth shift and the body buffer matter. If Alcaraz is teeing off on a second ball chest high from the middle, you will not survive many games.
If you are coaching a right‑hander against him this week, consider these Tokyo‑specific tweaks:
-
Deuce side, windless roof sessions: Shade half a step to the alley only if you commit to recovering back to the center after the chip. Do not stay in the alley channel or the ad corner becomes exposed to the inside‑out forehand on ball two.
-
Ad side, humid evenings: Plan for body serves that jump. Start with hands higher and choose the punch return, not a full swing. High contact with a long swing equals late contact.
-
Second serves under the roof: Expect a stronger kick. Stand a fraction deeper and commit to heavy spin back to the center stripe so the plus one arrives at shoulder height, not at the waist where he is most dangerous.
Scouting checklist you can use in 20 minutes
Bring this list to the match. It is short and practical.
- First three ad‑court serves at 15‑all, 30‑all, 30‑40. Track location and ball shape. If two of three are body, activate the body buffer rule.
- Deuce 40‑15 or 40‑30. Watch for the quick wide slice to seal the game. If he goes there twice in a row, the next time you must plant for the T and react out.
- Second serves after long rallies. He often takes a little more margin. Stand a touch deeper and favor backhand heavy returns.
- Plus one forehand direction when the return lands deep center. If he defaults to inside‑out, play backhand line on ball two to meet his movement.
- Drop shot alerts. If your depth returns push him behind the baseline, expect the surprise drop on ball three. Stay honest with your weight on the split step.
Practice blocks that build the returner you need
For coaches running a 90‑minute session, here is a sample block focused on the Alcaraz serve phase.
- 20 minutes, body‑jam return tolerance: Server hits 40 balls at the returner’s torso. The returner uses a compact block only. Scoring is two points for any ball that lands deep middle, minus one for any ball that drifts wide.
- 20 minutes, deuce trap scenarios: Server calls the serve location only after contact. Returner executes the two‑choice trap plan. Coach feeds the second ball to simulate the plus one. The returner must send it to a pre‑called lane and then close forward.
- 20 minutes, chip and float control: Alternate five skids and five floats with immediate plus one fed by coach. The returner must win neutral within three balls or the point ends.
- 15 minutes, scoreboard pressure: Play games that start at 30‑all, serve to the deuce side first, then ad. The returner applies the side‑specific plan and must journal locations after each game.
- 15 minutes, video and breath work: Quick review of two sequences on court. Then run a two‑minute breath reset protocol so the player can execute under late‑set pressure without rushing the split step.
Off‑court training is the most underused lever in tennis. OffCourt unlocks it with personalized physical and mental programs built from how you actually play. Pair this return block with lower‑body strength for stable split steps, neck and shoulder mobility for cleaner contact on body serves, and a short visualization routine that rehearses your two or three return choices per side.
What to watch as he chases the Tokyo title and heads indoors
- How many body serves he uses on ad points in Tokyo. If opponents start reading that tendency, expect a quick shift back to T serves and inside‑out forehands.
- Whether returners commit to deep middle as a default. The more they aim to the corners, the more space they hand him on ball two.
- If the roof is closed, expect his kick and slice to get even more surgical. Train for bounce‑height changes and decide in advance which balls you will chip versus punch.
- For European indoor events after Asia, the court tends to play a fraction quicker through the middle. The depth shift still works, but the chip needs to be lower and shorter to keep him from half‑volleying forward. Add a low skidding chip to the T into your toolbox for those weeks.
The bottom line
Alcaraz’s serve plus one is not a mystery, it is a moving target that punishes hesitation. The formula that produced 98 holds out of 101 in New York is already showing up in Tokyo. You cannot out‑guess it, but you can build a return plan that moves his strike zone, blunts his forehand, and steals the middle of the court on ball two. Start with depth shifts, prepare to handle the body serve without panic, learn when to chip and when to float, and set deuce‑court traps that funnel his patterns into your strengths.
Coaches and juniors, run the drills above this week. Parents, help count locations and log scores so the practice has feedback. Then layer in off‑court work with OffCourt and make the plan part of the player, not just a page in a notebook. The Asian swing rewards good habits and clear choices. Build both now, and watch service games that once felt inevitable suddenly feel playable.
Ready to turn this plan into sessions your player will stick with all month? Reach out to your coach, schedule two focused return blocks this week, and use OffCourt to create the supporting strength and mental routines that make it stick.